Therapy for chronic pain: what it can actually do (and what it can’t)

The medical pathway has thinned out. You’ve had the appointments, the scans, perhaps the procedures. You’ve been told the words “manage” and “long-term” and “pain clinic” enough times to know roughly what’s coming next. And somewhere along the way, someone has mentioned therapy.

If you’re reading this, you’ve probably stalled at the same question. If no one has been able to stop the pain, what is therapy supposed to do?

It’s a fair question, and most articles I’ve read on it skirt round the answer. Some imply, gently, that therapy will help you accept the pain and stop fighting it, as if acceptance is a switch you can throw. Others promise tools and techniques, the kind that sound useful in a brochure and harder to translate when you’re tired and sore at four in the afternoon.

This is an honest piece on what therapy for chronic pain actually does, and what it doesn’t. I work with people in this position every week. Some come because the pain has been there for a couple of years, some for far longer than that. The work isn’t a shortcut and it isn’t magic, but it does change things, often in ways people don’t expect.

What therapy for chronic pain isn’t

It helps to clear a few things out of the way first.

Therapy isn’t trying to make the pain go away by changing how you think about it. The thinking-your-way-out-of-pain idea has been around for a long time and it doesn’t do justice to chronic pain or to therapy. Pain that has lasted months or years has set up real, physical loops in the nervous system. Those loops respond to a lot of things, but not to telling yourself the pain isn’t there.

It also isn’t built on the assumption that your pain is imagined or amplified. If you’ve been told “it’s just stress” or “have you tried mindfulness” by someone who clearly thought the answer was yes, you’ll know the version of therapy that lands like another dismissal. That isn’t what good therapy for pain looks like. The starting point is that the pain is real, the experience of it is real, and the question is what to do now that the medical side has done what it can.

And it isn’t a faster route than the medical one. People sometimes arrive hoping that talking to a psychologist will move things along that the GP and consultants couldn’t. It rarely does. Therapy works on a different layer of the same problem. It doesn’t replace pain management; it sits alongside it.

What it does do is harder to put on a poster, but worth setting out in plain terms.

What changes when pain is persistent

For most people I work with, the shift is from trying to fix the pain to trying to build a life that has room for it. That sentence is doing a lot of work, read it again.

When pain is short-term, fixing it is the right goal. You break a wrist, the wrist heals, the pain goes. The body’s threat system did its job by making you protect the wrist while it mended.

When pain has been around for a long time, the threat system doesn’t switch off in the same way. It stays loud. Movements that wouldn’t have registered before now feel risky. Plans get smaller. The world contracts to a shape that protects the painful part, often without you noticing it happening.

This is normal, by the way. It isn’t weakness, and it isn’t you exaggerating things. The nervous system is doing what it’s wired to do under conditions it wasn’t designed for. The cost is that the protective response, which was helpful in the short term, starts shrinking the rest of your life.

So the work moves to a different question. The medical version of the question, “how do I get rid of the pain”, has largely been answered already by the time someone reaches me. The question that opens up after that is “how do I keep the parts of life that matter to me, while pain is still here”. This is a bigger question than it sounds, and it usually takes a while before someone in pain can sit with it. Most people arrive with the first question and only later notice that the second one is the one they actually need to answer.

What the work tends to focus on

The work itself tends to focus on three things. They overlap, and the order varies, but they’re recognisable across most of the people I see.

Making more room for the pain to be there

A lot of energy goes into bracing against pain. Tensing the body, holding the breath, trying not to think about it, scanning for signs it’s getting worse. Bracing is exhausting and, paradoxically, it tends to make pain feel louder rather than quieter. The brain interprets the bracing as another signal that something dangerous is happening.

So a slow, careful piece of the work is learning what it’s like to let pain be in the room without fighting it quite so hard. The word “acceptance” gets used a lot here and I’m wary of it, because most people hear it and assume I’m asking for a brave face. What actually tends to happen is closer to stopping the wrestle with something you can’t pin down. People often describe it as the pain becoming smaller in their attention even when it hasn’t changed in intensity.

Protecting the parts of life that matter to you

Pain has a way of dictating the calendar. Whatever was important to you before starts being arranged around what the pain will allow today: work and relationships, the garden, walking the dog, music, the kids.

A lot of the work is taking stock of what those things are, and finding ways to keep doing them, in adapted forms, even on bad days. The adapted version is usually smaller and more sustainable than the push-through version someone has tried before, with the part that mattered to them held onto. People often arrive saying they’ve lost themselves; what they usually mean is that they’ve lost contact with the things that made them feel like themselves.

Working with the body’s stress response

Chronic pain and the body’s threat system feed each other. Pain ramps up stress; stress amplifies pain. It’s a loop, which means there are several places to interrupt it.

Some of the work is practical, learning to notice what the body is doing and what it does in response to small things like slower breathing, longer outbreaths, gentle movement. Some of it is broader, looking at the bigger sources of stress in your life and what can be done about them. For people whose pain is connected to a frightening medical experience, like a serious diagnosis, an emergency admission, or a procedure that went badly, that experience may need its own attention before the loop loosens fully.

What sessions actually look like

Sessions are weekly, online, fifty minutes. Most of what we do is talk. There’s no special equipment, no homework folder, no exercises you’ll dread between appointments.

The first few sessions are mostly listening and mapping. I want to know what your pain has been like, what you’ve already tried, what’s currently working and what isn’t, and what your life looks like around it. By the end of those sessions, I’ll usually have a sense of where the work is likely to focus, and I’ll share that with you.

After that, the rhythm shifts. We start trying small things between sessions, designed so we can both learn from whatever happens. Some weeks you’ll come back having tried something and noticed it shifted nothing; some weeks something tiny will have moved. Both are useful information.

One thing surprises some people. Sessions don’t always feel like progress. Some weeks will feel quietly important and some will feel like nothing happened. The work tends to compound, and the things that change rarely change in straight lines. People often notice that they’ve changed about three sessions after the change actually happened.

Most people I see come for between eight and twenty sessions, depending on what’s going on. Some keep coming for longer, on a less frequent rhythm, when life throws something new at them. There’s no fixed package and no requirement to commit beyond the next session.

When it’s worth talking to a therapist

It isn’t always obvious when therapy is the right next step. A few signals make it more likely.

Pain has been around for six months or more, and the time horizon for further medical change has stretched out. Your life has narrowed in ways you don’t want. You’re saying no to things you used to say yes to, and the no has become automatic rather than weighed up. The loop between pain and worry feels stuck on its own track, with each amplifying the other and no obvious way to break in. You’ve started feeling like a different person from who you were, and you’re not sure how to recognise the new version.

If any of those land, it might be worth a conversation. I offer a free fifteen-minute call where we can talk about what’s going on and whether the work I do is likely to be useful for you. There’s no obligation to book sessions afterwards, and it’s fine to come back to it later.

A short answer to the question we started with

If no one has been able to stop the pain, what is therapy supposed to do?

The straightforward answer is that it gives you room. Room for the things that matter to you to stay in the day, without bracing through every hour to keep them there. Space to feel like yourself again, even with this in the picture. And, over time, the pain becomes one thing happening rather than the only one.

That’s smaller than a fix, and bigger than it sounds. For many of the people I work with, it’s been the most useful thing they’ve done.


Comments

One response to “Therapy for chronic pain: what it can actually do (and what it can’t)”

  1. […] in therapy for chronic illness, and why it is not the soft option it sounds like. It builds on a recent post on what therapy for chronic illness can offer, and looks at one part of that work in more […]

Leave a Reply

Discover more from The Remote Therapy Space

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading